Skip to main content

Understanding the Causes of the War between the States

With the history of America's "Civil War" having recently reentered the political spotlight, it has become apparent just what precious little Americans know about their own country's history. Those who wish to truly understand the causes of the War between the States must first endeavor to understand the construction of the United States, that the United States were constituted as a Union of sovereign states. In this context, it is essential to understand that each state then reserved the right to secede from the Union, as articulated in the Declaration of Independence, throughout the Constitutional Conventions, and upon ratification of the Constitution. 

One must also study the Constitution of the Confederate States of America, the addresses and the statements issued by Lincoln and his administration, the Corwin Amendment, the history of the American Colonization Society, the political and economic implications of the Morrill Tariff and westward expansion, the implications of a General Government becoming such a force within the states, and the events and circumstances surrounding the battle at Fort Sumter after the State of South Carolina had already declared its secession from the Union; after the State of South Carolina had already demanded that the Union Army vacate the fort; and after the State of South Carolina had already offered compensation to the Union in return. 

Ultimately, the Union Army’s continued occupation of Fort Sumter, its Southern blockade, its imposition of onerous tariffs, and its incursion into the Southern States constituted treason as defined in Article III, Section 3, Clause 1 of the United States Constitution: "Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort." And, where the term "United States" appears within the Constitution, it is in the plural, regarding the States severally in their sovereign capacity as declared in the Declaration of Independence, as acknowledged in the Treaty of Paris, and as reaffirmed in the compacts which formed the Union. 

Ultimately, at the very core of the matter we find this: Slavery was not the cause of the Civil War. It was, however, one of the political issues named among the States’ declared causes for secession. There is a difference. In fact, had the Civil War ended within two years after it officially began at Fort Sumter — or within the even shorter timeframe expected by Lincoln — nobody today would connect the war to slavery, specifically because it was a war waged by Lincoln to "preserve the Union" and, by that, to preserve the General Government’s major tax base in the South. 

It was only several years into the war, after the issue of slavery became expedient to the cause of the Federals, that the Emancipation Proclamation was issued as a war measure to foment unrest in the South and to conscript slaves into the Union Army. To believe that the Civil War for both sides centered on the issue of slavery is to believe that the Allies’ efforts in World War II were inspired by the Holocaust or the plight of the Jews. That is to say that both beliefs are naive, unfounded in both reason and history.

For those interested in discovering the true history and the various events comprising this critically important part of American history, please read America's Founders on the Matter of States' Rights and America's Civil War: Not "Civil" and Not About Slavery.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Trump Victorious in 2024 Presidential Election

As of this hour, former President and now President-elect Donald Trump has secured his second term as the forty-seventh President of the United States. Trump’s victory comes after winning key battleground states Wisconsin, Michigan, Nevada, Arizona, Pennsylvania, and Georgia.  As for the popular vote, Trump was victorious there as well, winning by a one-and-a-half-percent margin. Despite these results, it’s evident that there remains a significant social and political problem in the United States, where politically-motivated violence, social unrest, crime and general instability have become rampant over the years since the death of George Floyd.  However, I’d say the fact that it was even this close is ominous for the years ahead. This was as clear as it gets for an election, that the incumbents (both Biden and Harris) are wholly unfit for any office, that they present a real and present danger where they’re allowed within twelve thousand miles of a school zone, let alone any...
Post a Comment
Read more

Failure by Design

In the case for liberty, there is certainly some tolerance for error or failure, as it is generally suffered by the individual and not brought upon anyone by design . Wherever anyone seeks to empower government, however, one must be reasonably certain of the designs, the logic and the costs, and he must be equally honest about the unknowns as with the foreseeable consequences; after all, there is no margin for error where those designs are administered by the barrel of a gun.  One must necessarily remember that government is a monopoly on force and coercion, that force and coercion serve together as the modifying distinction between government and enterprise. It is a kind of force and coercion not by spirit or intention of written law but in accordance with the letter and understanding of the enforcers in their own time, in their own limited judgment and impaired conscience. As opposed to a state of liberty, where mistakes, failures and crimes are unavoidable in the face of human f...
Post a Comment
Read more

Rally for Route 66!

Keep up the fight for the Mother Road! Rally for Route 66! There is a lot at stake in preserving this irreplaceable monument to American history, not merely as a tourist attraction but as a means to permitting a glimpse into our past, as a means to virtual time-travel into a time and space otherwise inaccessible, as a means to capturing the imaginations of future generations and to preserving the memory of our forbears in both form and spirit.  We are nothing without reverence for our forbears, without our heritage or our identity as a people, without the preserved memory of our history. Without these reminders, without the tangible connections to our past and the efforts which have forged our path and come to define us, without these monuments to the pioneering and the innovative, we are destined to forget all of that which makes us uniquely human, all of that which has afforded us so much insight and abundance, all of that which has given us pause to reflect and remember and to a...
Post a Comment
Read more